Evidence–practice gap for dental sealant application: results from a dental practice-based research network in Japan

Academic Article


  • © 2016 FDI World Dental Federation Purpose: The study aims were: (i) to examine dentist practice patterns regarding treatment recommendations for dental sealants; and (ii) to identify characteristics associated with this recommendation. Methods: The study was performed using a cross-sectional questionnaire survey (Clinicaltrials.gov registration number NCT01680848). Participants were Japanese dentists (n = 282) recruited from the Dental Practice-based Research Network Japan. Three clinical photographs of the occlusal surface of a mandibular first molar were presented, portraying increasing depths of cavitation in a 12-year-old patient with high caries risk. Sealants would be an appropriate treatment in all three scenarios. We asked about the treatment decision for each case. We then performed multiple logistic regression analyses to evaluate associations between the decision to recommend sealants, and dentist, patient and practice characteristics. Results: Responses were obtained from 189 dentists (response rate = 67%). In the hypothetical scenarios, dentists’ recommendations for sealants for the 12-year-old patient varied from 16% to 26% across the three hypothetical clinical scenarios. Multiple logistic regression analysis indicated that dentist agreement with the efficacy of assessment for caries risk showed a significant association with the percentages of patients receiving sealants. Conclusions: Dentist practice patterns for sealant treatment recommendation show changes that are dependent on caries severity. The dentists’ recommendations for sealants for the 12-year-old patient were low for all three selected scenarios, based on indications for sealants in the American Dental Association guidelines. Recommending a sealant showed a significant relationship with the dentist having a higher agreement with efficacy of caries risk assessment.
  • Authors

    Published In

    Digital Object Identifier (doi)

    Author List

  • Yokoyama Y; Kakudate N; Sumida F; Matsumoto Y; Gilbert GH; Gordan VV
  • Start Page

  • 330
  • End Page

  • 336
  • Volume

  • 66
  • Issue

  • 6