A randomized comparison of crystalloid and blood-containing cardioplegic solutions in 60 patients

Academic Article


  • To determine whether adding blood to a cardioplegic solution affects myocardial preservation, a randomized prospective study was carried out in 60 patients undergoing coronary revascularization to compare the effects of crystalloid potassium cardioplegics (group C) and potassium cardioplegic solutions to which blood has been added (group B) on markers of myocardial metabolism (lactate, inorganic phosphate, base deficit release, glucose and lactate uptake, oxygen extraction), myocardial damage (creatine kinase [CK]-MB levels), and cardiac performance (cardiac index and left atrial pressure). The solution with added blood had a significantly (p < .05) greater oxygen content, a lower pH, and higher concentrations of potassium, calcium, sodium, and glucose. In group B patients there was a suggestion (p < .06) of greater uptake of oxygen during the beginning of the initial cardioplegic infusion. During reperfusion there was no evidence of differential release of the metabolites of anaerobiosis and myocardial oxygen extraction and glucose and lactate uptake were similarly depressed in both groups. Likewise, CK-MB release after bypass was the same in both groups. Prompt, adequate functional recovery of cardiac index and left atrial pressure was observed in both groups. It was concluded that although there may be more oxygen available from the blood-containing solution during early infusion, there is no evidence that under the conditions of this investigation adding blood to cardioplegic solution improves myocardial preservation.
  • Authors

    Published In

  • Circulation  Journal
  • Digital Object Identifier (doi)

    Author List

  • Buttner EE; Karp RB; Reves JG; Oparil S; Brummett C; McDaniel HG; Smith LR; Kreusch G
  • Start Page

  • 973
  • End Page

  • 982
  • Volume

  • 69
  • Issue

  • 5